Quote:
Originally Posted by JamalBrown
What's the pros and cons of fixed gear and single speed?
|
[Freewheeling] Single Speed:
Pros:
• ability to coast when you are tired or riding in a technical area where you want to concentrate solely on steering.
• somewhat safer as you do not have the pedal-strike issues when leaning into turns and the issues that can relate to the chain jumping off the cog and seizing the rear wheel. Not to mention the risk of finger amputation while wrenching on the bike.
• Less negative karma from the bike community as a whole.
Cons:
• generally loud while coasting (may have more to do with my choice of lower end freewheels than a flaw with the type of drivetrain in general though)
• less 'connection' to the bike as compared to FG.
• less street cred.
Fixed Gear:
Pros:
• most fun you can have on two wheels.
• better workout. you don't know how much you coast until you can't and that translates to increased performance even when going back to freewheeling multi-speed bikes.
• hard-to-describe feeling of the bike being almost a prosthetic part of you rather than just a vehicle you sit on top of and pedal.
• simple to clean and maintain as there are so few moving parts to get gunked up
• street cred.
Cons:
• bad karma from the rest of the cycling world as being just a toy for posers and hipsters who ride like idiots, brakeless, pissing off cars and pedestrians.
• safety- beyond riding brakeless which is a choice and not a direct implication of a fixed drivetrain, you are at increased risk of pedal strike while leaning into turns and if you aren't careful you can easily lose a digit while wrenching on the bike on a stand.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JamalBrown
Which do YOU think is better?
|
Personally, I prefer fixed gear. I have a flip/flop hub so I can ride either way but 95% of the riding I do on that bike is using the fixed cog. I love the hard-to-describe feeling of oneness with the bike being able to adjust your speed up or down through the use of just your legs. I also like how inexpensive it was for a bike of reasonable quality. The workout I get from a bike that won't let me coast is unquestionably better than the same ride would be if I only pedaled about half the time and coasted the rest.
I hate that when I mention "fixed gear" it seems like everyone immediately thinks of the stereotype of brakeless hipsters pissing off traffic by riding like ******s but I hope that by not riding like that I can help change that image a little. I ♥ my fixed gear and (after the new paint job cures and I get it put back together) I look forward to riding it this spring.