No Nose Saddles

Discussion in 'General Bike Discussion' started by TxCyclist, Aug 13, 2009.

  1. TxCyclist

    TxCyclist Administrator Staff Member Admin Staff

    2,475
    11
    38
    Got this in an e-mail. Never heard of this before?

     
  2. Industry_Hack

    Industry_Hack Total noob (& forum admin) Admin Staff Tavern Member

    12,350
    651
    113
    I made one kid, that's enough. And my fiance' is ten years younger than me, so blood flow has not been an issue.

    Unless I had a genuine medical need for an ugly seat, I'll keep the one I have. Sounds like an bandaid for poor fit.
     

  3. mtndoc

    mtndoc New Member

    346
    0
    0
    Dean,
    I read the study, it has some leaps of logic that aren't supported by the data. It is also not a true medical supported document, looks like it at first glance, but the conclusions don't really relate to the data presented. The study group is also flawed as it truly only relates to bicycle cops, and women in particular. I read a lot of literature(goes with the job)and this is one I would throw in the trash after reviewing the data. I'm keeping my saddle!!
    DrB
     
  4. Reesh

    Reesh and Monkeypants

    12
    0
    0
    I think we probably use the nose more than we think we do-- especially when riding really hard. Mountain biking or road biking doesn't matter for me. I use the nose to control the bike.

    Anyway, when I get the money, I'm investing in a Selle SMP! I think my undercarriage would thank me.
     
  5. Burr

    Burr Cranking Old Guy

    712
    0
    0
    I have two of those Spealized prostrate saddles and one wonderful old Brooks with springs.

    I have the prostrate saddles on my road and touring bike and the brooks on my city bike.

    I just offset the nose about a quarter of an inch (to the right, don’t know why right).

    Feels fine to me. What bothers me is lose shorts in the front rubbing, this hurts and I have to stop and adjust ASAP.

    The Terry Saddle for women works well I understand. I remember I had a female partner and it hurt her until she got a Terry.
     
    Last edited: Aug 24, 2009
  6. Reesh

    Reesh and Monkeypants

    12
    0
    0
    I have heard both ends of the spectrum from women about the Terry... I think it comes down to personal preference. I could probably use a new saddle, and I'd love to test out a Selle SMP... but they cost at least an arm, if not a leg as well. :hate:
     
  7. hophead

    hophead New Member Tavern Member

    1,501
    1
    0
    What the H-E double toothpicks is a "prostrate saddle?"
     
  8. Smiley

    Smiley New Member

    465
    0
    0
    Not for me, Terry was very uncomfortable. Also tried the 'gel' seats, can't remember by who, but I could tell 2 minutes into the ride it was not fo rme.

    I like my Selle Italia. Would have bought the SMP, but as Reesh mentioned, it is very pricey.
     
  9. funetical

    funetical Slowin it up.

    4,299
    0
    0
    it seems like we would take all steps necessary to prevent junk numbness. The study proves correlation not causation, and that's good enough for me. I just wonder if it applies to casual cyclist, and if so if the chances are greater or lesser. Seems like it would be greater due to the less developed muscles.
     
  10. hophead

    hophead New Member Tavern Member

    1,501
    1
    0
    My thoughts are, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. My boys don't get numb and everything works just fine.
     
  11. mtndoc

    mtndoc New Member

    346
    0
    0
    The study listed is only a review of data, not a true "study". All one can induce is that the people who were studied have a problem, not what causes it or why it occurs. It might not have anything to do with bike saddle, might have to do with job stresses related to specifics of job or a hundred other factors not discussed, I wouldn't put a lot of stock in this particular study as they truly don't know why this occured. I would recommend you use your own experience and find the saddle that works best for you and not rely on a flawed supposition such as the one quoted.

    I also like being able to control the bike with my thighs when standing up, this has been mentioned in this thread already.

    Just my evaluation and opinion of this study, I'm stickin to my nosed saddle.
    DrB
     
  12. funetical

    funetical Slowin it up.

    4,299
    0
    0
    So far so good sure, but at the first weird tingle tell me you wouldn't change.
     
  13. mtndoc

    mtndoc New Member

    346
    0
    0
    Actually I get a lot of "weird" tingles, if I worried about them all I be more neurotic than I already am, so i don't worry too much about it. On this issue, worryin about it could be more trouble that the actuality.

    Studies I've seen so far are still pretty inconclusive, but I encourage everyone to use best judgement, if a problem exists it will in all likelyhood make it worse. It depends on your age, guys it isn't a matter of "if" you are gonna have prostrate problems, but of "when", whether you ride a bike or not, if you live long enough it will happen. At 56 it is subject very near and dear to my heart, or something like that, so I try to keep up on it as best I can, so far no problems.

    I average about 14hrs/wk on bike.
    DrB
     
    Last edited: Aug 24, 2009
  14. Burr

    Burr Cranking Old Guy

    712
    0
    0
    I ain't to smart.

    "Prostate Saddles" Google it