With that response I'd say you're not that dumb! I agree with everything you said and would add two points. Rim width and tire size. My new felt came with 2.2's and really skinny disc specific rims. I'm used to running 1.95's on the width of a Sun Rhino Lite or Mavic 261. I noticed that with the new combination I'm putting in only 45lbs. When running the wider rims with 1.95's I'm like you-up in the 50 to 60 lb range. With thinner rims and bigger tires you'll have less contact patch even when running the same pressure that you're used to, making your ride alot more sketchy.Depends on your weight, terrain, style of riding, and conditions. I'm roughly 250 pounds and ride some fairly rocky-rooty terrain so I run about 50 psi front and around 60 psi rear to help prevent pinch-flats around every corner. The higher pressure also causes traction problems on steep hill climbs, but a little walking up a bad hill is better than a lot of walking to the car with a flat.
HAHA, yeah... I'm really not that dumb. I just look that way. I do have semi-narrow rims, but I'm also limited to about 1.95 tires on the back of my Mt. Fuji Pro. It has a very close rear triangle. I'd love to be able to run a 2.35 in the rear but there is no chance of clearance. I am contemplating trying out the tubeless tires and lower psi to see what that does for me though.With that response I'd say you're not that dumb! I agree with everything you said and would add two points. Rim width and tire size. My new felt came with 2.2's and really skinny disc specific rims. I'm used to running 1.95's on the width of a Sun Rhino Lite or Mavic 261. I noticed that with the new combination I'm putting in only 45lbs. When running the wider rims with 1.95's I'm like you-up in the 50 to 60 lb range. With thinner rims and bigger tires you'll have less contact patch even when running the same pressure that you're used to, making your ride alot more sketchy.
So to make it simple, I'd agree with my Bear cousin and say your weight will be the first factor then you can get as technical as you want from there. If you're over 200lbs than you will more than likely want to start at 45lbs but probably won't go beyond 60lbs offroad.
You'll notice the added rolling resistance really fast. Remember the old smoke 2.1? I tried running those front and rear and it felt like I was driving a monster truck...not that I ever have. 2.35 would be great if you are doing a lot of DH but isn't your bike an XC? If you're like me-a wanna be xc rider, I'd stick with the 1.95. I'm going back when my 2.2's wear out.HAHA, yeah... I'm really not that dumb. I just look that way. I do have semi-narrow rims, but I'm also limited to about 1.95 tires on the back of my Mt. Fuji Pro. It has a very close rear triangle. I'd love to be able to run a 2.35 in the rear but there is no chance of clearance. I am contemplating trying out the tubeless tires and lower psi to see what that does for me though.
I am more of a cross country rider... My logic behind running a wider rear tire is to get more traction on the hill climbs. I have a lot of problems with tire spin in the crux of a steep climb. The tubeless tire allow you to run lower pressures with no real chance of a pinch flat. I'm not sure if I am gonna make the switch or not. Just another idea I'm checking into. Hopefully I can continue my recent weight-loss trend and get my weight down to a point that I won't need to change the tire setup. I'm down 12 pounds in the last few weeks... Only about 30 pounds to go. lol.You'll notice the added rolling resistance really fast. Remember the old smoke 2.1? I tried running those front and rear and it felt like I was driving a monster truck...not that I ever have. 2.35 would be great if you are doing a lot of DH but isn't your bike an XC? If you're like me-a wanna be xc rider, I'd stick with the 1.95. I'm going back when my 2.2's wear out.
So are you saying that with tubeless you can run lower pressures with the same tire floatation? That's interesting. I haven't done very much research into them, I just slime and go...
I agree. I'm 175lbs and use 2.1" width for XC. If it's a fast packed dirt I will run between 35 & 40psi for speed. If it's slower technical with a lot of rocks & roots I'll drop down to 20-25psi for added grip and cushion.Depends on your weight, terrain, style of riding, and conditions.